The Third Dimension of Financialization: Electronification, Intraday Institutional Trading, and Commodity Market Quality

  • Provides the first detailed empirical evidence on the financialization of intraday trading activity in WTI futures.

  • Shows that electronification of U.S. crude oil futures trading in 2006 brought about a massive growth in intraday activity by “non-commercial” institutional financial traders.

  • Shows that this development had a first-order positive impact on market liquidity (spreads, depth) and pricing efficiency.

The Collateral Rule: An Empirical Analysis of the CDS Market

  • The paper tests whether initial margin held at a clearinghouse against credit swap positions can be estimated using a traditional VaR measure.

  • This analysis finds that VaR is often not a good proxy for actual initial margin levels, with collected margin often far higher than would be implied by the VaR calculation. Other proxies which more highly weight extreme events are found to better align with empirical margin.

Automated Trading in Futures Markets

  • The paper investigates the prevalence of automation across futures markets and tracks changes over the period of 2012 through 2016.

  • Automation during that period is often highest in financially based instruments like FX futures, the S&P Emini and U.S. Treasuries. Automation is commonly lower for physical commodities, including grains, softs and livestock.

The Futures Trading Landscape

  • The paper examines how different participant classes, including asset managers, banks, and corporates, make use of futures markets, and how this may have changed through time.

  • Participation levels by class can vary widely across futures contracts, with end-users/corporates having a much larger presence in physical commodities and others, like asset managers, much more concentrated in financial products.

Liquidity in Select Futures Markets

  • The paper measures the liquidity of a few highly liquid futures products (U.S. Treasuries, the S&P E-mini) across a number of different metrics.

  • Generally, liquidity across the selected contracts has remained steady or has improved in recent years, at least relative to a few metrics like order book depth, bid-ask spreads and realized execution costs.

  • More generally, the paper highlights a set of measures that can be utilized on an ongoing basis for futures liquidity monitoring.

Speed and Latency in Treasury and e-Mini Futures Contracts – Part 2

  • The paper analyzes how long it takes for traders to place new orders in the limit order book.

  • The paper also studies what kinds of signals traders observe from the changes in the limit order book might affect the time to new order placement.

  • E-mini futures, ten-year treasury futures, and thirty-year treasury futures are explored.

  • he paper finds that manual traders pay more attention to changes in the limit order book than algorithmic traders.